based on:

"One Min Halacha" #15
By HaRav Yosef-Yeshaya Braun
member of the 3-man Lubavitch rabbinical court of Crown Heights, Brooklyn.

For text and WhatsApp video subscriptions, etc, go to //halacha2go.com.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~

SHABBAT Law #s04: "At my son's bar-mitzvah, can he, I, his older brother, and both grandfathers all be honored with an aliyah?"

A father and a son may not be called to the Torah one after the other. Similarly, two brothers should not be called to the Torah one after another. (If nevertheless they have already been called, depending on the circumstances, sometimes they will have to take the aliyah or at least go up and stand on the Bima [reading platform].)

The main reason given for not allowing two close family members to get subsequent aliyot is Ayin Hara, not to cause any 'evil eye' [dangerous envy].

Some people are also careful with a father and a grandchild, particularly if it is a son's son. Some people are even particular with a father and a son-in-law, although strictly speaking, these cases are not included. [In all these cases,] if they were called, they should go up for the aliyah.

[Thus, assuming neither grandfather is a Kohen or Levi, the order could be: 3rd aliyah: father, 4th: maternal grandfather, 5th: paternal grandfather, 7th: brother, 8th (maftir - aliyah plus haforah reading): bar mitzvah boy.]

Copyright © 2016 Halacha2go, All rights reserved.

Please note that these laws apply in general situations. In unique circumstances, a different law may apply.
If you are unsure whether what you read here applies to your particular situation, please consult a rabbinic authority.

Back to Top          Back to One-Minute Laws Index


Redesign and implementation - By WEB-ACTION